S4 Filming — Convent Ave, Harlem (Fan-spotted)

About This Location

Reddit user u/quirkytortle walked past a row of townhouses on Convent Avenue in Harlem and spotted production crews unloading furniture into a brownstone. Crucially, the furniture was labelled "Peggy NY house" — confirming this as the filming location for Peggy Scott's New York home in Season 4. Additional boxes were marked "Fane," which may indicate a new character or storyline.

This is a significant find for fans of the show. Peggy Scott, played by Denée Benton, is one of the series' central characters — an aspiring journalist and writer navigating both the Black elite and white high society of 1880s New York. The choice to film her home scenes on Convent Avenue is historically resonant: this stretch of Hamilton Heights was home to many prominent Black professionals and intellectuals in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Fan-spotted by Reddit user u/quirkytortle, March 2026. Furniture labels ("Peggy NY house," "Fane") provide strong evidence of official production activity. The specific block (around 142nd/143rd St) is approximate.

About Convent Avenue

Convent Avenue takes its name from the Convent of the Sacred Heart, which occupied the hilltop site now home to City College of New York. The residential rowhouses that line the street were built in the 1880s and 1890s as Hamilton Heights developed into an affluent neighborhood. The blocks between 140th and 145th Streets were designated a New York City historic district, preserving one of Manhattan's most cohesive collections of Romanesque Revival and Renaissance Revival brownstones. By the early 20th century, the neighborhood became a center of Black cultural and intellectual life — W.E.B. Du Bois, Thurgood Marshall, and Duke Ellington all lived nearby. For the show's purposes, the intact 1880s architecture makes it an ideal stand-in for the world Peggy Scott would have inhabited.

Nearby Locations